Retrenchment is a "no-fault" dismissal, but South African law still demands a fair reason, a fair procedure and a paper trail that proves both. The first document in that trail is the retrenchment letter, and errors in it are a quick route to losing an unfair dismissal case.
A lawful process normally needs two letters: a written notice that opens consultation under section 189(3) of the Labour Relations Act (LRA), and a termination notice issued only after consultation ends. This guide explains the retrenchment process in South Africa step by step and ends with a template you can adapt.
TL;DR
- A valid letter is not a "you are fired" note. It starts with a section 189(3) notice inviting consultation, and the termination letter comes last.
- The first notice must disclose ten items in writing, from the reasons and alternatives to severance pay and assistance offered.
- Minimum notice periods are 1, 2 or 4 weeks, and statutory severance pay is at least one week's pay per completed year of service.
- Employers with more than 50 staff that reach the thresholds in section 189A face a longer process of at least 60 days.
- Retrenchment must be a last resort, with genuine consultation and fair, objective selection criteria.
What Is a Retrenchment Letter?
A retrenchment letter is the written communication employers use when dismissing employees for operational requirements, meaning the economic, technological, structural or similar needs of the business. Because the process is staged, you will usually issue:
- The section 189(3) notice (the invitation to consult).
- Written records of consultation.
- The notice of termination.
- Final pay documents, including a certificate of service.
The law that governs these documents is mainly sections 189 and 189A of the LRA, and sections 37, 38, 41 and 42 of the Basic Conditions of Employment Act (BCEA). Contracts and collective agreements can improve on the statutory minimums but cannot bypass section 189.
How to Write a Retrenchment Letter: 8 Steps
Step 1: Document the real business reason
State the true operational reason and keep it consistent. In a case discussed in Bowmans' retrenchment playbook, the notice cited a partnership while consultation revealed economic reasons, and the shifting explanation contributed to a finding of procedural unfairness.
Step 2: Explore alternatives
Dismissal must be a last resort. Consider vacancies, redeployment, reduced overtime, voluntary packages and bumping. Record how you assessed each option and why you rejected it.
Step 3: Identify the consulting parties
Address the letter to the right party: a collective agreement party, workplace forum, registered union with affected members, or the employees themselves.
Step 4: Draft the section 189(3) notice
The notice must invite consultation and disclose, in writing, all relevant information. That includes:
- The reasons for the proposed dismissals.
- Alternatives considered and why each was rejected.
- The number of employees likely to be affected and their job categories.
- The proposed selection method.
- The timing of the dismissals.
- The severance pay proposed.
- Assistance offered to affected employees.
- The possibility of future re-employment.
- The total number of employees you employ.
- The number dismissed for operational reasons in the previous 12 months.
One Labour Court decision found a retrenchment fair despite a missing notice, but as Bowmans' analysis of that case explains, the court stressed the unusual facts, so issuing the notice every time remains the safe course.
Step 5: Consult in good faith
Consultation should be a genuine attempt to reach consensus on avoiding dismissals, reducing numbers, changing timing and mitigating the effects. Answer every proposal in writing, with reasons if you reject it.
Step 6: Apply fair selection criteria
Selection must follow criteria agreed with the consulting parties or, failing agreement, criteria that are fair and objective. The employer carries the onus of proving this, as the Labour Appeal Court confirmed in Kenco Engineering. Last in, first out (LIFO) is the most accepted method, usually subject to retaining key skills.
Step 7: Calculate what each employee is owed
- Notice: Under the BCEA, one week for six months' service or less, two weeks for more than six months up to a year, and four weeks for one year or more. You may pay in lieu of notice.
- Severance pay: At least one week's remuneration per completed year of continuous service, unless the employee unreasonably refuses suitable alternative work.
- Leave: Pay out all accrued, unused annual leave.
Step 8: Issue the termination letter and finish the admin
Once consultation (and any mandatory waiting period) is complete, give each selected employee a written notice stating the reason, notice period, last working day, itemised payments and any agreed assistance. Employers must also provide a certificate of service under section 42 of the BCEA, and complete the UIF paperwork.
Is Section 189A Relevant to You?
Section 189A applies to employers with more than 50 employees that contemplate dismissing at least 10 (up to 200 staff), 20 (201 to 300), 30 (301 to 400), 40 (401 to 500) or 50 (over 500) employees, counting operational dismissals in the previous 12 months. A facilitator can be requested from the CCMA within 15 days of the notice, and termination notices cannot be issued until 60 days have passed.
Retrenchment Letter Template (Section 189(3) Notice)
Adapt this outline and have it checked by a lawyer.
Subject: Notice in terms of section 189(3) of the Labour Relations Act, 1995: invitation to consult
Dear [name],
[Company] is contemplating dismissing employees for operational reasons and invites you to consult on the following:
- Reasons: [factual explanation with supporting information]
- Alternatives considered: [each alternative and why rejected]
- Employees affected: [number and job categories]; we employ [number] and dismissed [number] for operational reasons in the past 12 months
- Selection method: [for example LIFO, subject to critical skills]
- Timing: [period]
- Severance pay: [proposal]
- Assistance and re-employment: [support offered, future vacancies]
- Consultation: first meeting on [date, time, venue]; written representations by [date]
Yours faithfully, [name, title]
Common Mistakes to Avoid
- Issuing termination notices before consultation, or pre-selecting employees by name.
- Changing reasons mid-process, or rejecting alternatives without justification, which Bowmans' playbook lists among the key pitfalls.
- Using subjective or discriminatory selection criteria.
- Under-calculating severance. Disputes can go to the CCMA or a bargaining council.
Conclusion
A well-drafted retrenchment letter shows that the business reason is genuine, alternatives were considered, employees were properly heard and the final decision was fair. Start with a complete section 189(3) notice, consult in good faith, apply objective criteria, pay notice and severance correctly and finish with a clear termination letter. Check whether section 189A applies, and take legal advice before anything goes out.



