Artificial intelligence is making it easier for jobseekers to prepare polished resumes and cover letters, but this is also changing how employers evaluate candidates. As applications become more refined, recruiters are placing greater importance on what candidates can demonstrate during interviews rather than relying entirely on written applications.
Katie Dolgin, founder and CEO of Toronto-based recruitment firm Found People Inc., says AI-generated applications have made it harder for employers to distinguish between candidates based on their resumes alone.
Speaking to Canadian HR Reporter, Dolgin explained that when applicants use similar AI tools to match job descriptions and improve their applications, written documents may provide less insight into their actual abilities.
Hiring Is Shifting Towards Judgement and Practical Skills
According to Dolgin, employers are increasingly looking beyond whether candidates possess the technical skills listed in their applications. They also want to understand how individuals approach unfamiliar problems, make decisions and work with others.
She identifies judgement, emotional intelligence, communication and the ability to build trust as important qualities during recruitment.
These capabilities become particularly valuable for startups and businesses operating with relatively small teams, where employees may need to handle responsibilities beyond a narrowly defined job description.
For recruiters, this means evaluating how candidates think and respond in practical situations, rather than relying solely on qualifications and keywords.
Employers Are Rethinking Resumes Screening and Interviews
A Robert Half survey of more than 1,500 hiring managers found that 79% believe they can identify when AI has been used in a job application.
However, recognising AI involvement is not the same as establishing whether a candidate has the required skills.
Dolgin recommends using structured interviews, practical work samples and more detailed reference checks to understand candidates' actual experience.
For example, a candidate who claims to have improved a business process should be able to explain the challenges involved, the approaches they considered and what they learned from the experience.
Such questions help recruiters assess practical understanding rather than simply evaluating how well an applicant presents their achievements in writing.
Employer Ghosting Continues to Affect Jobseekers
The recruitment experience is also influenced by how employers communicate with candidates throughout the hiring process.
Employer ghosting, where applicants receive no response or meaningful update after applying or interviewing, remains a concern among Canadian jobseekers.
Employment Hero's January 2026 survey of more than 1,000 Canadians found that 70% of jobseekers said being ghosted by employers had affected their mental health and motivation to continue searching for work.
Dolgin believes organisations can improve the experience by keeping recruitment processes shorter, communicating realistic timelines and providing feedback promptly.
Clear communication is especially important when candidates have invested considerable time preparing applications and attending interviews.
AI Screening Raises Questions About Transparency and Accountability
Although AI can help recruitment teams identify potential candidates and manage large volumes of applications, Dolgin cautions against allowing automated screening systems to make hiring decisions without meaningful human oversight.
She argues that systems relying heavily on conventional career paths and keyword matching could overlook candidates with transferable skills or less traditional professional backgrounds.
Her position is that employers should maintain accountability for screening decisions and ensure that automated recommendations can be reviewed.
Jobseekers have also expressed reservations about fully automated recruitment. Employment Hero's survey found that only 13% of respondents were fully comfortable with AI screening resumes on its own.
Ontario Introduces AI Disclosure Requirements for Employers
Transparency around AI-assisted recruitment is also becoming a regulatory issue in Canada.
Since January 1, 2026, Ontario employers with at least 25 employees have been required to disclose in publicly advertised job postings whether AI is used to screen, assess or select applicants.
The requirement forms part of changes to Ontario's Employment Standards Act, 2000. It also applies when an employer engages a third-party recruitment firm to conduct AI-assisted screening or assessment on its behalf.
The rule is intended to give applicants greater visibility into how technology is used during recruitment. It does not prohibit employers from using AI in hiring, but requires disclosure when the specified conditions apply.
Keeping Human Judgement at the Centre of Recruitment
AI can help recruiters source candidates, organise applications and reduce repetitive screening tasks. However, employers still need to assess whether applicants can perform the work, communicate effectively and contribute to their teams.
For HR professionals, this means combining technology with structured interviews, practical assessments, relevant reference checks and clear candidate communication.
As AI becomes more common in job applications and recruitment systems, the quality of the hiring process will increasingly depend on how effectively organisations balance automation with human judgement.
The objective is not to eliminate AI from recruitment, but to ensure that it supports better hiring decisions without replacing the human assessment needed to make them.



