Ontario's Human Rights Tribunal has dismissed a disability discrimination application involving an employee who experienced a serious medical emergency at work and later raised concerns about returning to her job. The Tribunal found that her employer had offered several return-to-work options, but she did not take steps to clarify whether those arrangements could address her concerns.
The decision, issued on November 4, 2026, concerns Vitality Assurance Vacations and Living Waters Resorts. It examines both the employer's responsibility to accommodate a worker with a disability and the employee's obligation to participate in the accommodation process.
Employee's Medical Condition and Workplace Concerns
The employee collapsed at the employer's administrative office in October 2018 and was diagnosed with Reversible Cerebral Vasoconstriction Syndrome (RCVS). After returning to work approximately three weeks later, she continued to experience cognitive difficulties affecting memory, learning and her ability to manage stress.
She kept her manager informed about hospital visits, specialist appointments and medical investigations. However, she did not submit a formal accommodation request at that stage, and the employer did not ask her to complete a functional abilities form.
In August 2019, she moved to the tour office for lighter duties. She informed her new manager about her medical condition and requested the removal of a plug-in air freshener. The request led to further disagreement over how her workplace concerns were being handled.
She subsequently filed a formal complaint alleging inappropriate treatment and failure to respect her medical accommodation needs before going on medical leave.
Employer Offers Three Return-to-Work Options
Following the complaint, the employer initiated an investigation and maintained communication with the employee through its executive vice-president.
In January 2020, the employer proposed three possible arrangements to facilitate her return:
- Preparing packages alongside a former manager from the administrative office.
- Performing administrative duties.
- Taking on a different position involving graphic design work.
The employee was concerned that these positions might still require her to interact with the manager involved in her earlier complaint.
However, the proposed arrangements did not specify whether that manager would be involved. Instead of asking the employer to clarify the reporting arrangements or workplace locations, the employee informed the company on February 18, 2020, that returning would not be possible.
The Tribunal found that the employer reasonably interpreted her communication as a resignation. It also considered her earlier application for Canada Pension Plan disability benefits when assessing her intention to leave the employment relationship.
Formal Medical Documentation Was Not Required to Trigger Accommodation Duties
An important aspect of the decision was the Tribunal's finding that the employer's duty to accommodate had been triggered even without a formal written request or medical documentation specifically outlining accommodation requirements.
The Tribunal considered the employee's communications, messages and testimony as evidence that the employer knew about her medical condition and related workplace needs.
The reasoning reflects the Ontario Human Rights Commission's guidance that employers must be alert to situations where an employee may require accommodation, even when the employee has not made a specific formal request.
For HR teams, this reinforces the importance of responding appropriately when employees disclose medical difficulties or circumstances that may affect their ability to work.
Employees Must Cooperate With Reasonable Accommodation Efforts
The Tribunal also considered the employee's responsibility to participate in the accommodation process.
Relying on the Supreme Court of Canada's decision in Central Okanagan School District No. 23 v. Renaud, the Tribunal noted that employees must cooperate with reasonable efforts to find an appropriate workplace accommodation.
In this case, the employer had offered several alternative assignments intended to address the employee's concerns. The Tribunal found no evidence that these arrangements would necessarily have required her to work with the manager involved in her complaint.
It concluded that the employee should have sought clarification about the proposed arrangements rather than concluding that a return to the organisation was impossible.
The Tribunal therefore found that she had not fulfilled her reciprocal responsibility to cooperate in the accommodation process.
Reprisal Allegations Also Dismissed
The employee also alleged that changes to her computer password and missing training notes were examples of retaliation following her workplace complaint.
However, the Tribunal found that the password had been changed for security reasons and that there was insufficient evidence to establish retaliatory intent.
The reprisal allegations were therefore dismissed, along with the other claims in the application.
What the Decision Means for HR and Return-to-Work Management
The decision highlights the importance of treating workplace accommodation as a continuing process involving communication and cooperation from both sides.
For HR professionals, an employee's informal disclosure of a medical condition should not be ignored simply because a formal accommodation request has not been submitted. Employers should make appropriate inquiries, understand the employee's functional needs and consider reasonable adjustments to duties or working arrangements.
At the same time, employees are expected to participate constructively in discussions about suitable alternatives.
Organisations should document the options offered, explain reporting arrangements, address employees' concerns and maintain clear communication throughout medical leave and return-to-work planning.
The ruling is based on the particular evidence in this case. Its broader HR lesson is that effective disability accommodation requires more than proposing alternative duties: it depends on an informed, individualised and cooperative process.



